Never rely on assumptions in sports. Before the 2007 season, the Phillies thought they had a surplus of starting pitching, with 6 guys for 5 spots. But by midseason, Freddie Garcia and Jon Leiber were on the disabled list and Adam Eaton was pretty much a disaster. The unheralded Kyle Kendrick was rushed up from double-A in June and remained a regular starter the rest of the season, something no one could have foreseen heading into 2007.
Similar thinking was abudant about Penn State's defensive line heading into spring practice 2008. There appeared to be an embarrassment of riches in terms of top-flight talent, and depth to match probably any program in Division I-A.
About six months later, defensive tackles Phil Taylor (Baylor) and Chris Baker (Hampton) have been kicked out of the program and transferred to other schools, defensive tackle Devon Still and defensive end Jerome Hayes have sustained season-ending injuries, and All-America defensive end Maurice Evans and starting defensive tackle Abe Koroma have been suspended from the team for an unknown period of time due to police finding marijuana at their campus apartment one week ago.
All of that, and Penn State still doesn't really even need to think about switching to the 3-4, let alone something more drastic. At defensive end, fifth-year senior Josh Gaines is showing signs of finishing a solid but unspectacular Penn State career with a big senior campaign and Aaron Maybin is a legitimate quality starter on the other side. Redshirt freshmen Eric Latimore and Kevion Latham bring talent if not game experience to the backup defensive end spots. The main worry here is not putting Gaines and Maybin in a position where they will wear down in conference play - a concern that will be reduced if Evans is permitted to return to the lineup.
At defensive tackle, true freshman Jack Crawford has moved up the depth chart into the rotation. With Ollie Ogbu and Jared Odrick starting, and Chima Okoli and Tom McEowen as backups, there appears to be enough on hand here as well. And a return from Koroma has not been ruled out.
But in all cases, this assumes no more serious injuries or off-field "distractions."
Who else is listed on the official roster at these positions?
Well, 367-pound freshman Brandon Ware from Harrisburg is listed as a defensive tackle but I'm pretty sure Penn State wants to red-shirt him and get him trimmed down a bit before he plays.
Also listed, simply as a defensive lineman, is 255-pound freshman Mikel Berry from Upper Arlington, OH. That concludes what I know about him - presumably he's a preferred walk-on. Another freshman is 250-pound Pete Massaro from Marple-Newtown High School, near Philadelphia. I'm pretty sure he's another red-shirt candidate.
The roster also lists DE Jonathan Stewart, 236 pounds, sophomore, from North Huntington, PA.
How about some "thinking outside the box" ideas? Well, I'm pretty sure fifth-year senior LB Tyrell Sales at least practiced at defensive end in the past and at 238 pounds, he's no smaller than Tim Shaw when he played DE as a senior. But I think the move of Shaw to DE was intended to get him, Paul Posluzsny, Dan Connor and Sean Lee all in the starting lineup at the same time. And with Lee on the sidelines this year, I suspect Joe Paterno and Tom Bradley will want to keep Sales right where he is, as the de-facto leader of the linebacker corps.
With Penn State's outrageous depth at tight end, with Mickey Shuler Jr., Andrew Quarless (who was reinstated before Saturday's game despite being a resident of the same apartment as Koroma and Evans), the much-touted Andrew Szczerba, and true freshman Mark Wedderburn, perhaps fifth tight end Jon Ditto, who goes about 230 pounds, could try some work at defensive end. For that matter, maybe they could look at Wedderburn there, as well, if necessary.
At defensive tackle, after years of the offensive line borrowing talent from Larry Johnson's d-line recruiting (Levi Brown, Charles Rush), maybe turnaround is fair play. Fifth-year senior Mike Lucian has played both defensive tackle and end in his PSU career, but he's technically the top backup at center and both guard spots, so I think Lucian is staying put.
But how about giving some of the deeper depth chart guys like Quinn Barham (287 pounds) or Ako Poti (316 pounds) a look at defensive tackle in practice? It probably couldn't hurt.
So as usual, there are plenty of bodies to throw at the problem at Penn State. But without question, the best solution is for Evans and Koroma to return to the lineup.
In the meantime, poor Jerome Hayes. What did he ever do to deserve two torn-up knees in two years?